Photo of How to breed Schrödinger’s cats

How to breed Schrödinger’s cats

by Juanita Bawagan Quantum Information Science 17.05.2017

Alexander Lvovsky is a physicist, a CIFAR Quantum Information Science Fellow and most recently, a Schrödinger’s cat breeder.

In 1935, German physicist Erwin Schrödinger proposed a thought experiment where a cat, hidden from the observer, is in a superposition of two states: it is both alive and dead. Schrödinger’s cat was intended to show how radically different the macroscopic world we see is from the microscopic world governed by the laws of quantum physics.

However, with recent advances, Schrödinger’s thought experiment no longer seems as unrealistic.

Modern physicists use “Schrödinger cats” to mean objects in a quantum superposition of two states with opposite properties. In optics, this is a superposition of two classical states of light where the fields of the electromagnetic waves point in opposite directions at once.

Physicists have been able to generate small Schrödinger cat states, but current methods limit their size to three to four photons. In order to create larger, higher-energy states, Lvovsky’s team of University of Calgary and Russian Quantum Center scientists sought out to combine these states. Their results were published in Nature Photonics.

“We developed a technique to construct a larger Schrodinger cat state out of smaller ones,” Lvovsky explains.

The idea of ​​the Schrödinger cat breeding experiment was first proposed in a 2003 article by University of Queensland physicist Timothy Ralph. The experiment relies on causing interference of two cats on a beam splitter. This leads to an entangled state in the two output channels of that beam splitter. In one of these channels, a special detector is placed. In the event this detector shows a certain result, a cat is born in the second output whose energy is more than twice that of the initial one.

Schrödinger-cat-experiment
The experiment causes interference of two “cats” on a beam splitter. This leads to an entangled state in the two output channels of that beam splitter. In one of these channels, a special detector is placed. In the event this detector shows a certain result, a “cat” is born in the second output whose energy is more than twice that of the initial one. (Credit: Nature Photonics)

At the Russian Quantum Center’s Optics Lab, Lvovsky’s team successfully converted a pair of negative squeezed Schrödinger cats into a larger positive one. They saw an increase from 1.3 to 3.4 photons on average, which is comparable with the largest optical Schrödinger cats ever produced by other methods. They generated several thousand such enlarged cats in their experiment.

While the experiment has not yet yielded the biggest Schrödinger cat state, it demonstrates a method that could be used to obtain one. Lvovsky says this instrument could allow physicists to breed these larger cats into even bigger ones that would ultimately be visible to the naked eye.

The study addresses a question at the heart of Lvovsky’s research : At what point do the laws of quantum physics yield to classical physics?

“We want to enlarge the cats until we stop seeing quantum effects. Maybe we’ll never stop seeing them, who knows,” Lvovsky says, adding that there is no experimental evidence that would tell us whether the laws of quantum physics are universal or if they stop working at a certain degree of macroscopicity.

In addition to probing the boundary between the quantum and classical worlds, macroscopic Schrödinger cat states would have applications in quantum communications, teleportation and cryptography.

For now, Lvovsky is taking a break from breeding Schrödinger cats to take on another challenge.

His new experiment focuses on building an entangled state between a Schrödinger cat and the polarization of a single photon. Polarized photons and Schrödinger cat states are two ways of encoding quantum information. These encodings have different benefits and this experiment would look at how to convert one into the other so the fortes of both approaches can be exploited at once.


 “Enlargement of optical Schrödinger’s cat states” was published in Nature Photonics May 1, 2017.

Related Ideas

News | Cosmology & Gravity

Third detection of gravitational waves

The first detection of gravitational waves has been compared to opening a new window on the universe. With the third...

Video | Cosmology & Gravity

Pulsars – Perfect Clocks for Physics

Associate Fellow Scott Ransom discusses pulsars at the Untangling the Cosmos Symposium.

Video | Cosmology & Gravity

Gazing at the Cosmos… From 6,800 Feet Underground

Senior Fellow Mark Chen‘s presentation at CIFAR’s Untangling the Cosmos Symposium.

Video | Cosmology & Gravity

The Extreme Universe

An introduction to the fourth panel at Untangling the Cosmos. 

Video | Cosmology & Gravity

Astrophysics from the Stratosphere

Barth Netterfield, senior fellow in the Cosmology & Gravity program, presents at the Untangling the Cosmos event.

Video | Cosmology & Gravity

Ripples of the Universe; Gravitational Waves

Senior Fellow Luis Lehner presents at CIFAR’s Untangling the Cosmos Symposium.